JUPEBUse of EnglishLogical Reasoning

Read the passage and answer the question. 'Enrolment at the community secondary school in Otukpo has doubled since the state government began the free lunch programme. This proves that free lunch is the reason parents now send their children to school.' Which of the following, if true, most weakens the writer's conclusion?

AParents in Otukpo have always valued education highly.
BThe lunch is served at midday every school day.
CThe state government intends to extend the programme to other schools.
DIn the same period, the school stopped charging fees and a new road made it reachable from six neighbouring villages.CORRECT
AI
Toaster Teacher
Why the answer is D, and why the others tempt you.
The writer assumes that free lunch alone explains the rise in enrolment. Evidence that fees were abolished and access improved at the same time offers other causes for the increase, so the conclusion no longer follows. The timing of the lunch, the parents' general attitude and the government's plans do not challenge the claimed cause.
Want this in Pidgin, Yoruba, Igbo or Hausa? Sign up free →

Practice more Use of English questions

JUPEB Use of English has thousands more questions like this — with Worked answers on every one.